Hey everyone, itβs been a while!
My name is Chris.
Iβm an illustrator, author, and one of the co-founders of Band of Bards (an independent publishing house based in Buffalo, NY). As much as this space is about what Iβll be doing, Iβm also aiming to help other creators, and spread some positivity with my platform (not to mention dispel and demystify a little bit of how the publishing industry works from my own point of view).
**Admittedly, this one isnβt the most positive, and Iβm not having the best year so far. At this point we all can only try to be better.
Want to help grow βA Great and Terrible Blogβ? Refer a friend! Itβs easy, and the more people you refer earns you awesome rewards like a free digital comic, access to a private discord, and more!
Note: I wrote most of this back in November 2024. Honestly I felt like the whole world was crashing down around me at the time, and Iβm glad I waited a bit before I fired this off into the ether. Now that Diamond Comic Distributors has announced what is going to ultimately become itβs demise (bankruptcy), looking backβ¦ I canβt say that I didnβt see it coming.
Iβm less angry right now than I was back in November. Never-the-less, letβs talk about the challenge that was 2024β¦ and then lets talk about what we can do better for the future.
Isnβt comics romantic? (Spoiler Alert: Itβs not)
I canβt believe itβs been almost four years since Tim and I started Band of Bards. Bright-eyed, bushy-tailed, and ready to change an industry. Lofty goals and aspirations for sureβ¦ especially after you spend some real time and money trying, only to realize that the industry, (and some of the people in it) donβt actually want to change. Iβm not a conspiracy theorist, the reality is that some of those people are good at pretending to be in your camp, while actively working against you to lift themselves upβ¦ instead of everyone.
Listen, Iβm not here to throw anyone under the bus or cancel them for not living up to the expectations they created for themselves, or of usβ¦ Hell, we havenβt been able to live up to the early hype we generated yet, and weβre four years in.
So what is it than? Lack of understanding? Romanticization of the direct market? A little bit of both actually, and unfortunately a lot more.
(Delays, cancellations, and Vendor dependency)
The comics industry as a whole runs on razor thin margins (and weβre not just talking money, weβre talking time too.) When your book goes up for sale in a catalog like Previews youβve got around thirty days to sell the book to stores. Once that window closes it takes about a week (sometimes two weeks) for us to get the purchase order from the distributor, and by the time we have it the clock has already been running.
Being beholden to the industry we are trying to change is not what we ever wanted.
The order for the books has to be placed, artwork reviewed and approved, the books then are printed, shipped, and hopefully get to the distributors warehouse in time so they then can be re-shipped to whatever other corresponding warehouse they need to get to⦠AND THEN shipped to the Comic Shop.
Suffice to say the last six+ months have been a kind of living hell of vendor issues, creator issues, distribution issues, and our own internal issues.. and while I donβt feel like weβve personally dropped the ball, it all gets to a point where everyone is just tired, and needs a break. Iβm not going to go into specifics because whatβs the point? The bigger question for me that I needed to solve was, how do we get back on track and how do we bring Band of Bards back to itβs original mission? Because frankly, being beholden to the industry we are trying to change is not what we ever wanted.
Realization has to come quick, and self-reflecting on a system built where you run yourself ragged working for a never-ending set of deadlines, is quite literally the death of creativity.
That, and regardless of how well-oiled of a machine youβve got running it only takes one wrench to fuck it all up for everyone.
Iβve spent the last four years of my life working to help lift up other people and their projects for the better, but lately it seems to have been for worse. I feel like every single choice that I had to make this past year was extremely difficult and was not met with a modicum of grace. Iβm not infallible, criticism is OK, and in some situations appropriate. All of it feels like itβs things mostly out of my controlβ like the unexpected darkness of a print vendorβs printing. Nothing feels better than to be told Iβm doing my job poorly, and reading a shitty sub-tweet about it.
Hind-sight is 20/20 though, and Itβs easy to have a negative opinion about something that didnβt go your way. Itβs also like having an asshole on your elbow.
Itβs easy to complain to the wilds of the internet and never have to mind all the missing context. Just go and get your Twitter pitty parade, and collect your 10 seconds of clout. Your private group chat will hold your hand, and reassure you that I am indeed a horrible person.
I digress. Iβm not going to blame this person for being upset about the print quality, itβs a bummer for sure. The fellow is a great writer and he deserves way more recognition for his work than he getsβ¦ but Iβm not a fan of the personal swipe at me, when I tried my best to make it right, and with what limited resources I had to work with at the time. Thatβs all.
Truth is I canβt be mad at this guy. Nobody really knows the extent of the bull-shit weβve been dealing withβ mostly what Iβve been dealing with for six months and essentially on my own.
This industry can be a cold and selfish place. I try to operate for the most part from a place of understanding, and sure can I lose my patience? Absolutely, but I donβt lack the gumption to take accountability for my mistakes.
People donβt have to be grateful for the work Iβve done for them (for free). I donβt need to be told βThank youβ. I would be happy to just not read or hear about how my peers talk shit, and rip me apart in some private βpseudoβ community forum or chat, when the direct market doesnβt satisfy their expectations. Thatβs not my fault. Itβs not satisfying ANYONEβS expectations. Thatβs your romanticization of an industry that was broken long before me.
Publishing is fun, until it isnβt anymore.
The fact is that I love building books, and promoting books, and helping other creators grow. Band of Bards isnβt an IP Farm, weβre not collecting others work to get rich quick (we donβt have any money). This industry is incredibly difficult on all of our emotions, our brains, and very clearly our egos. We need to be a bit more tempered, and a bit more understanding if weβre going to survive.
So⦠where do we go from here?
I think itβs pretty obvious that this isnβt the only pile of shit we had to wade through in 2024, but this blog post isnβt about airing my grievances, itβs about working for the future.
The comic industry saw this weird revival during COVID, where entertainment was paramount, money was plentiful, and IP licensing was abundant. Many a publisher formed their entire business model on this, After Shock, Scout, IDW and more reaped fortunes and now lay mostly dormant.
Itβs weird because on the internet itβs easy to have anonymity for your hardships. These are companies with (allegedly) big money from investors. Where did it go? Itβs hard to watch companies indiscriminately squander dollars and lucrative IP deals. To see them flounder, knowing damn well you could have done some real good with only a portion of those funds.
We havenβt been financially lucky, no one has knocked down our door to spoon feed us cash.
Publishing is fun, until it isnβt anymore.
The plan from here on out is to try and do our best to support the creators, and the community that mean so much to us. That means that things will change.
Some of the things that Band of Bards is doing requires us to dig in and sew roots in our local community. Weβre looking for a space, big enough to hold a production facility. Weβre seeking funding from New York State to buy a state-of-the-art digital printing press, and weβre going to open a collaborative creative hub that can help us provide increased services to the independent creator community we love; and hopefully ease some of the costs of productionβ¦ not to mention be able to better control the quality of those products being made.
Weβve closed submissions for now. Please donβt be discouraged, theyβll open again later in 2025 or early 2026, but in earnestβ¦ weβve done a terrible job of keeping up on them, and instead of pumping out new series after new series, weβre going to focus and help cultivate and grow the amazing slate of creators we currently have under contract. We made a commitment to them and thatβs where my primary focus has been since June. Expanding to the book market and giving these awesome people more opportunities to create including novels, anthologies, and trades. Finding new avenues for their work and continuing to support these amazing up and coming digital marketplaces like Comix.one, GlobalComix, Drive Thru, and LibraryPass are a priority. Maybe that also includes focusing a little bit more on ourselves too.
Thatβs not to say that there arenβt new stories coming in 2025, so just please keep your eyes peeled. Weβve always been in the business of being transparent, so it wouldnβt be right not to give everyone some kind of update on what has been going on. Itβs chaotic, but we have a plan.
Weβre not dead yet.
I appreciate you, and want you to succeedβ¦ even if (for whatever reason it is) you donβt like me. Weβre much stronger together than we are apart.
Peace & Love
Chris
P.S. I promise there will be a Great & Terrible update next newsletter.
Wishing you luck with the production facility and printer!
Good luck to you on the print facility! We had a go at it when we were trying to scale and now have so many cautionary tales. I now oversee a more successful print facility(book adjacent) for my day job. If you have any questions, feel free to reach out.